FurnitureCore
Search Twitter Facebook Digital HFBusiness Magazine Pinterest Google
Advertisement
[Ad_40_Under_40]

Get the latest industry scoop

Subscribe
rss

Monthly Issue

From Home Furnishing Business

Cover Story: SHOPPING BEHAVIOR EVOLVES AS THE PANDEMIC CONTINUES

Slowly consumers returned to shopping at regular home furniture stores, not so much in quantity, but with a commitment to purchase leading to higher close rates and average tickets.

Higher WRITTEN SALES
averaging more than 50%— and at times doubling the same week last year—created an exuberance along with a fatigued sales team. Beyond what was obviously pent-up demand, there was a feeling that consumers had rediscovered their homes and would continue to allocate disposable income to home furnishings. The statistics supported that optimistic outlook. According to consumer personal expenditures (CPE), furniture has rebounded, recapturing the loss in March/April.

To better understand this shift, FurnitureCore, Inc., parent company to Home Furnishings Business, conducted a national survey of consumers who purchased furniture after March of 2020 to those that purchased in 2019.

Without a doubt, the COVID-19 pandemic caused a seismic shift in the consumers’ lifestyle. In general, our focus moved toward the home and away from travel. The benefi - ciary of this shift has been furniture along with other large purchases that had “stay at home” appeal. The most immediate need was home computers to address the transition to virtual learning and working from home (56% increase) and communication (29% increase). Leisure travel declined (3%), but not as much as the purchase of new cars. Table A compares the ranking of importance with “1” being the most important of five major purchases.

The belief is that once the immediate need for computers and communications are met, there will be a continuing shift to the importance of furniture.

As with most major purchases, the acquisition satisfi ed an internal need as well as an external statement to friends and acquaintances. After the pandemic, the external satisfaction has become more important. As can be seen from TABLE B, the external statements have become more important, such as refl ected by the consumer’s sense of STYLE and PROSPERITY.

Over the past twenty plus years, acquiring home furnishings has migrated from the “lady of the house” to a more joint endeavor. Interestingly enough, with time on their hands, the male has pursued furnishings with a passion. Table D compares the before and after.

This trend could be significant considering that males are more inclined to purchase online. There has been a sizeable shift in who initiates the furniture purchase. Again, the male leads the way as can be seen in Table E.

This is a signifi cant change that will impact how furniture is advertised. What are the advertising messages that will infl uence the male compared to female? All of this will be addressed later.

With this shift in the buying process, was there a change in the basic motivation for the home furnishings expenditure? The change in lifestyle dictated by the pandemic has created a surge in home purchases. As can be seen in Table F this surge has been refl ected in purchases instigated by recent moves and remodeling.

A special note should be made in regard to a signifi cant increase in buying for the second home. Free from the constraint of working at the physical offi ce, consumers escaped to the mountains and the seashore.

Following the trends of the previous fi ndings, the male overwhelmingly ventured out into the new world of shopping using a mask and following social distancing recommendations. Table G presents the statistics.

The survey fi ndings supported the anecdotal evidence that consumers turned to the Internet to conduct research before venturing out to the stores with 56.37% indicating the Internet was the fi rst step in the buying process, up from 47.98% the year before. Traditional advertising, such as television, newspapers, and magazines declined to be replaced by recommendations from friends and relatives. Table H contains the breakdown.

This finding was substantiated by a national sample of traditional furniture retailers’ unique visitors to their website.

However, note the trending down of visits to the Internet after Labor Day. Should we have concerns? After the initial shock of being sidelined by being designated as “non-essential” independent retailers fought back and retained their share of the consumer demand. However, the Internet gained a signifi cant share of the market. Table J presents the statistics.

It is interesting to note the loss in the lifestyle stores and regional chains. A contributing factor could have been the length of time stores were closed initially. Owner/operators are more driven to keep the doors open. Contrary to popular thought, after the pandemic shutdown the online home furnishings customers were not first-time online purchasers based upon this national survey.

No matter the experience level of the online purchaser, the concerns were the same, but the inability to “see and touch” was amplifi ed during the shutdown.

The impact of the pandemic has not been refl ected in how far the consumer is willing to travel to purchase furniture. However, in recent years as furniture retailers have added locations to make it easier for consumers, the concept of furniture shopping being defi ned as “destination” has all but disappeared. Across the nation in large and small markets 10-24 miles is the norm. Table M illustrates.

If the distance driven has not signifi cantly decreased, the time spent shopping has begun to decline. With 57% of consumers fi nishing the process in less than two weeks, this indicates the furniture retailer must be prepared to close the sale. This points out the growing necessity to begin the selling/ buying process on the phone with a more interactive retailer website using “chat” and email. Table N illustrates.

This reduction in time spent shopping has been driven by a reduction in the number of retailers shopped. The trend to fewer retailers shopped driven by increased pre-shopping research on the Internet will be accelerated by the pandemic as can be seen from Table 0.

In this period of intense demand, the reputation of the manufacturer has surged in importance (15.4% – 21.89%) and is indicated as most important while perceived quality and design declined as a purchase motivator. Price increased slightly. Table P provides the statistics.

It should be noted that general merchandise retailers, such as Big Lots and Target, are selling reputed brands like Broyhill. Obviously with the disruption, new requirements have become necessities. In the retail experience, consumers ranked the importance of these new requirements and confi rmed that the use of masks was most important compared to the other requirements. Table Q summarizes.

With all the noise around the signifi cant changes in everyday living, furniture retailers are perceived to be doing a good job by more than 50% of the consumers. However, we should have some concerns when we compare independent furniture retailers to the Internet.

Our challenge is to reestablish brick and mortar to provide the best consumer experience. Systematic changes provide opportunities.

Cover Story: STATE OF THE INDUSTRY

As can be seen from Graphic 1, with all the turmoil, the result was a dismal 1.8% down in the second quarter. However, with the conversion of the substantial backlog at the end of June, for some more than 30%, the industry soared in the third quarter to what we believe will be a growth of 10.1%. Unfortunately, this irrational exuberance will not continue and the industry will decline, we believe, to a 2.0% growth for the fourth quarter for the end of the year. After all the angst, a meager 3.7% growth year over year for 2021 and a slight rebound to 4.0% in 2020. What caused this irrational exuberance? Simply put, the consumers were encouraged to stay at home and not spend. And the nation sent significant stimulus in the form of checks and enhanced unemployment.

This created a major increase in DISPOSABLE INCOME never before experienced. Graphic 2 illustrates. But the party may be over. At this point, no more stimulus is forthcoming from the federal government. The job losses thought to be temporary now appear to be permanent with small business support (PPP Loans) seemingly exhausted. As with other downturns, now the best predictors will be CONSUMER CONFIDENCE and UNEMPLOYMENT.

Consumer confidence fell 40% from its near-term peak in 2018 with the corresponding decrease in furniture consumer spending. At this point, consumer confidence has not reached the level of the Great Recession; however, the consumer has not fully absorbed the impact of the job loss. Graphic 3 presents the trends.

What is real is the unemployment. In one short period of time, 30 million jobs were gone. While many believed it would be short term, it has seen a third of the loss return to work. However, each month another million jobs lost is added to the rolls. Graphic 4 illustrates. This time, furniture spending held back— there are many theories as to why, such as people being forced to “shelter in place” or work at home becoming a permanent condition. The future trends are not clear. The following sections present the analytics behind our forecasts. This forecast will be modified and adjusted as we move through the year. This is followed by the insight of three of the recognized experts in the industry.

With all of our perspective, we may find our way through the fog of the new normal.

Cover Story: A CLEAR VISION: The Future in Focus

The dramatic impact that the coronavirus has had on the world this year is undeniable. The first half of 2020 was an exercise in adaptation as COVID-19 continued to affect our lives, our jobs and our businesses. But the second half of 2020 is a different story: we need to plan how to evolve—and take control of the year.

In the midst of all this uncertainty we set out to find the Class of 2020 not knowing what to expect. What we received was the largest number of nominations in the history of the program, ranging from a VP who got his start in furniture because of a dead car battery, to a 30-something CFO who restructured $25M in bank debt resulting in a covenant free mortgage. It is a forward-looking class with vitality and muscle that promises to sustain long-term growth.

Our vision for the Forty Under 40 has always been to find, recognize, and celebrate the young talent in our industry. Those that are or want to be leaders who can create a roadmap that defines where the business is, where it wants to go, and how to get there. “Shining a light on the rising talent in our industry is more pertinent than ever, especially as the vision for 2020 has shifted its course,” said Doug Culmone, president and CEO, Storis. “As digital and tech-center initiatives rise in importance, the future leaders in our industry will be paving the path for the industry’s future as a whole.”

As we introduce you to the Class of 2020 you will find some of the most promising young people in the industry. They have focus, integrity, inner drive, and the desire to succeed, along with genuine care for their company, teams, customers, and communities. They were selected for the meaningful contributions they have made in their stillyoung careers. No matter how you measure success, this year’s Forty Under 40 are focused on a clear vision to help their companies reach their goals. So, to the Class of 2020 we say, congratulations! We are passing the torch to you to help create a clear vision for tomorrow. To you, our readers, we say sit back, get comfortable and get to know the Class of 2020.


Brian Adams, 32
Vice President –
International Sourcing Operations, Procurement, Quality, & Regulatory Affairs Ashley Furniture Industries

Brian has demonstrated his passion and commitment to Ashley Furniture and the furniture industry from the start of his career as a Regulatory Analyst. His numerous responsibilities are critical to Ashley’s operations. This, coupled with his community philanthropic commitments, defines him. Brian and his team manage a purchasing portfolio of over $2B for Ashley. He has been instrumental in developing a variety of processes to ensure Ashley achieves the best value throughout their supply chain. Due to COVID-19 and Brian’s early foresight related to anti-dumping duties, he and his team initiated over 120 new vendor relationships throughout Southeast Asia. This required moving over $300M of China-based products to non-China vendors, including the launch of three new countries for material sourcing.

Brian serves as a mentor to other Ashley employees and works with them weekly on the development of their career. He serves as a leader for the Chippewa County 4-H program and volunteers for Ashley for the Arts, one of Wisconsin’s largest charity events. He also volunteers at the American Society for Testing Materials for Furniture Safety and Bunk Beds creating standards to keep children safe.


Gina D’Amore Bauerle, 35
Interior Designer/ Partner D’Amore Interiors

Growing up in a family owned home furnishings business, D’Armore Interiors, Gina began work in the retail environment at the age of 12. By 18, she began offering design services and became the top producing salesperson. After college, Gina spearheaded the marketing responsibilities for the business. Today, she manages a majority of the company operations and is responsible for more than two-thirds of gross sales. Under her leadership, the business expanded to offer complete interior design services and offers its own line of products, which are designed and made inhouse. Gina has also created new product lines for various vendors under her social media brand, Design Boss Gina. She has won 18 awards for her interior design projects and has been published 13 times with full editorial features in regional, national, and international publications. She is passionate about letting her generation know that when you put your heart and soul into what you do, great things can happen!

Gina and D’Amore Interiors support the Children’s Diabetes foundation and Drifters Hearts of Hope, an organization dedicated to saving horses from the slaughter pipeline.

Marcus Bontrager, 33
President Fusion Designs

Furniture First member

Marcus is a true team leader, innovator, and motivator through his passion at Fusion Designs where he oversees operations, new product development, marketing, and sales strategy. He also recruits and trains team members for manufacturing, finishing, and shipping. Focused on what is best for the company to maximize production and produce quality furniture for customers, his quick problem solving, hands on training, and strong work ethic earned him the respect of the company’s employees and business partners.

In 2008 when the economy was going backwards, Marcus established the Fusion Designs brand and took the company to new heights. By the time the economy recovered, Fusion Designs had a stronghold on the high end market by implementing lean manufacturing to produce products faster with less waste. When Fusion Designs bought Borkholder Furniture in early 2020, Marcus led the transition for both parties and neither company missed a beat.

Marcus is an active and strong supporter of his local church. He also supports and donates to Onetreeplanted.org where the mission is to leave the world beautiful for future generations.


Jordan Boyst, 36
Director of Partnerships Home Furnishings Association

Jordan is a powerhouse who stepped into a leadership role at the HFA and created a pathway for more robust partner relationships. He oversees all partnerships between non-retailers and the Association. Leaning into his exceptional analytical skills, Jordan streamlined reporting processes utilizing technology to build a program that allows members to call in and receive a concierge-based approach to problem solving, created a lead aggregator to help non-retailers connect with retailers more effectively, and developed a format for non-retailers to receive daily data about the retailers that come to market. He is also a key stakeholder in the redesign of the High Point Market Retailer Resource Center. As a leader, he provides feedback, support, and strategic direction for his team to enable them to achieve their goals and expand the value of their department.

Jordan finds ways to connect to good causes through the groups he belongs to. His Rugby team hosts a “Toys for Tots” toy drive every year. He writes letters of encouragement to foster children who recently graduated and will enter the world outside the foster care system, offering hope and real-world advice.


David Cartlidge, 32
Senior Product Manager Corsicana Mattress Company

David is one of the bedding industry’s rising stars with 10 years of retail and manufacturing experience. He is currently responsible for developing customer-specifi c products and new product lines at Corsicana Matt ress Co., the sixth largest bedding manufacturer in the U.S., while overseeing its existing product portfolio and tracking productivity of various matt ress models. He has used his retail experience gleaned during his time at Art Van Furniture to develop matt ress collections that resonate with consumers. David joined Art Van Furniture in 2009 where, at the age of 24, he became the youngest buyer in the company. Here, he helped spearhead the industry movement to focus on adjustable power bases as a key category, nett ing the retailer more than $10M in added profi t over the next few years.

David annually donates time to The Pantry House, which serves underprivileged communities by providing after-school activities, learning supplies, and other essentials. At Art Van Furniture, he started a promotion geared toward donating matt resses to the less fortunate, granting families brand new matt resses for Christmas through the retailer’s partnerships. Cartlidge is also an avid blood donor.


Alex Cihak, 30
Vice President of Business Development
Elements International

At Elements International, Alex is currently responsible for leading the sales team of over 35 independent sales reps and sales managers. He also masterminds the overall margin for Elements’ business, which includes all import product categories and domestic upholstery business at Style-Line. As Alex moved into this new role to help lead the sales team, he has also maintained responsibility for managing inventory, turns, stock position, and margin for a domestic warehouse, warehouses in Vietnam and Malaysia, and several customer managed third party logistics warehouses in North America. It is rare to fi nd such a young person with his early mastery of the intricacies of furniture business who is so willing to both learn and teach. He rises to the occasion as a leader both internally with employees and externally with customers and suppliers. He has earned the respect of a seasoned sales team of industry veterans that he partners with to drive business forward. He also has managed and continues to take on special projects, and has earned and maintains his CPA License.


Will Conway, 35
Chief Operating Officer City Furniture

Beginning in Operations with City Furniture after college, then moving up the ranks to Senior Vice President of Operations, Will oversaw all delivery, warehousing, and customer care activities with over 1,000 associates on his team. Showing his determination, Will earned his MBA from Northwestern Kellogg while working at City Furniture. He has continued to grow in his current role as COO where he has taken on additional responsibilities including Operations, Human Resources, and is an integral part of City Furniture’s senior team that plans and manages all aspects of its business. Smart, dedicated, and with a steady management style to boot, he delivers on all his targets including developing an improved staffi ng forecast across the company, improving productivity, and beating budgets with his inherent thriftiness. Will has gained everyone’s respect and admiration.

Will supports all City Furniture philanthropy, including City Cares, a charity devoted to providing the homeless clothing, in addition to the Pine Crest School and his local church.


Colleen Daly, 39
Vice President Howard Elliott

For the last 13 years, Colleen has worked at Howard Elliott and helped build the business from the ground up. As vice president, she oversees operations, sales, and marketing. She manages all of the SKU data, customer service needs, warehouse capabilities, showroom set-up, and sales meetings. She keeps the website updated and relevant and seeks account and business development opportunities for the company. Through it all she still manages to fi nd time to help sales reps in every way. Her eff orts have helped increase Howard Elliott ’s e-com business over 400%! Colleen’s focus is on effi ciency and value. She pours her heart and soul into her job as well as the home furnishings industry in general. As a leader, she continually provides feedback and value to those around her, helping them grow as the company grows. Colleen participates in community service projects through ART (Accessories Resource Team). She volunteers as a group leader and donates products to projects for veterans. During the COVID-19 crisis, when she wasn’t at work Colleen helped coordinate the production and donation of masks in the Chicago area.


Craig Daniels, 29
Marketing Director Furniture Fair

FMG Buying Group member
Impact Consulting Performance Group member

Craig is a 4th generation family member at Furniture Fair where he oversees all marketing campaigns and collaborates on initiatives with product vendors, media agency suppliers, and non-profit organizations. Among his responsibilities are budgeting, contract negotiations, and maintaining Furniture Fair’s market share. He increases visibility for the company via their online presence and community engagement, and he pinpoints new target audiences. He communicates the company brand through social media events, non-profit charitable events, and the company’s sales team. Craig has also increased staff awareness of charitable activities in which Furniture Fair is engaged. He is the leader of Furniture Fair’s Values Board, which seeks to improve employee engagement and culture. He assists in orchestrating the annual golf outing supporting the Leukemia & Lymphoma Society helping raise over $1.5M. He also collaborates with other local businesses to host one of Cincinnati’s first female veteran’s military appreciation events. He led the company in its donation event of over one thousand hygiene products for local homeless female vets and helped raise awareness for opportunities available to them. He also holds a Six Sigma Certification.

Brittany Duncan, 31
Creative Implementation Officer Kathy Ireland Worldwide

Brittany Duncan is a millennial member of the kathy ireland Worldwide team. She began her career with kiWW during summer vacations from high school at the young age of 16 and had increasing responsibilities over the years. Today, she serves as creative implementation offi cer for Jon Carrasco, EVP and Global Creative Director of kiWW. Britt any implements Ms. Ireland and Mr. Carrasco’s creative discipline across multiple platforms including home, art, fashion, web, fi ne jewelry, packaging, trade shows, signage, and entertainment programming. She att ends each home market, and supervises a creative and administrative staff of over 40 people, many with MBAs and doctorates. Britt any has been recognized as a “Future Leader” by the International Home Furnishings Hall of Fame. She is passionate and knowledgeable not only about the home furnishings industry, but the needs of the clients on the B-to-B side and the B-to-C side. She conducts research and development for kathy ireland Worldwide, and is responsible for the creation and implementation of advertising and POP materials.

Britt any supports the Elizabeth Taylor AIDS Foundation, National Pediatric Cancer Foundation, and DIFFA


Ryan Egbert, 34
National Director of Distribution Malouf


Ryan oversees nearly four million square feet of distribution centers in four states and works with a team to manage over 200 distribution center employees. To ensure success, he determines processes, systems, and policies for warehouse operations. He also develops and manages onboarding and training. Many of the details customers love about Malouf are because of Ryan’s work, like drop-shipping, no minimum order quantities, and split case packs. When Malouf acquired a former Toys-R-Us distribution center in Texas, an advanced conveyor belt system had to be retrofi tt ed to work for their needs. Ryan partnered with software engineers and the chief information offi cer to customize the system allowing small-parcel items on the conveyor up to four times faster, freeing up manual labor for larger items. Ryan focuses on putt ing people fi rst by coaching and supporting his team members to develop leaders with emphasis on personal development is what sets him apart.

Ryan is one of the founding members of the Malouf Sustainability Council. He also had a major role in founding and continuing the popular Warehouse Sale fundraiser for the Malouf Foundation to support rescue and aftercare missions for child sex trafficking victims.


Sabrina Eouse, 38
CFO AFD HOME

Under Sabrina’s leadership, AFD Home has achieved a position of fi nancial stability from prior overhead debts by the restructuring of loans and major software advancements. Sabrina excels at providing executable business solutions. One pivotal achievement was the restructuring and refi nancing of an over $25M bank debt that occurred over three stages to fi nally secure a long term covenant free mortgage, allowing the team to refocus on profi table growth. She also facilitated the replacement of a 15-year old software system with a newly improved system that allowed her to cap the expenditure of the install and roll out to 30% below projection— with zero down time. Sabrina also manages the e-commerce team and spearheaded an automated connection between the software and their e-commerce platform, with no prior knowledge, for pennies on the dollar. Having seen her older brother fi ght childhood cancer, Sabrina became an advocate for Cancer Research. When a local 18-monthold girl was diagnosed with brain cancer Sabrina worked to raise funds and awareness. She also co-hosted an auction event to give toys to children for Christmas.


Steve Frey, 36
CEO Factory Mattress

Steve started working at the family business when he was just seven years old, sweeping and cleaning the warehouse. Although he worked for other companies as he grew older, he chose to work at Factory Mattress after college graduation. He moved into a sales position and achieved a very strong “be-back” and closing ratio. He earned the respect of the employees, expanded the company’s advertising programs, and formed a marketing and merchandising department. He also rebranded the company, enhanced the website, and helped grow the company from 14 to 19 locations. Steve worked with a consulting firm over the years to prepare to become president of the company. Since then he has improved the culture of the company and created a strong vision. He restructured all departments, upgraded store locations, opened four more locations and has two more pending for 2021. With annual sales of $17.8 M, Stephen’s goal is to hit $20M by the age of 40. With the help of vendors, Steve donated mattress sets to the victims of the Bastrop Wildfire, and the West Texas Fertilizer Plant Explosion. He also partners with the Season For Caring and has worked alongside The American Red Cross.


Justin Garner, 35
VP Corporate Retail Operations, 35 W.S. Badcock Corporation

Justin started with W.S. Badcock accidentally. His car battery died, so he walked into Badcock’s and started talking to the store manager to see if he could borrow jumper cables. Within an hour he was waiting on customers. That was 12 years ago. Today, Justin is one of the youngest executives to be promoted to vice president. His responsibilities include running the day-to-day of all company owned stores and directing the efforts of all of the employees working in corporate retail. He is charged with directing and managing the Dealer Retail Operations field team and coordinating their efforts to serve their dealer network and the 300+ stores they represent. He played an important role in the conversion of all dealer stores to the Sales Based Model, and was part of the complete overhaul to the Dealer Commission Model. Justin also served on the committee that implemented and rolled out the company’s E-Commerce platform, bringing the company into the online selling space for the first time. Justin has volunteered at his church to help feed the homeless. He also volunteers to speak at the University of Florida to their business and communications classes.


Deena Gardner, 39
Vice President of Marketing & Communications Reverie

Deena is not just passionate about helping people live better lives through the power of better sleep — she wants to change how the entire sleep solutions industry thinks about the traditional vendor-retailer relationship. She views it as a true alliance, and makes sure Reverie takes time to learn about each retailer’s business needs, opportunities, and frustrations. She also leads the inhouse marketing team with enthusiasm, innovation, and thoughtfulness to deliver the best results to partners and customers. Deena oversees the development and execution of marketing strategy for Reverie’s consumer and wholesale channels. Working closely with the company’s in-house creative team, she is constantly searching for more effective ways to communicate the link between better sleep and better health. Deena is an advocate for and supporter of the Sickle Cell Disease Association of America (SCDAA). Her passion is personal, tied to her own daughter’s diagnosis who has since been cured. She is a long-time volunteer with the American Cancer Society’s Relay for Life events in her community. As VP of Membership of WithIt, Deena serves on various committees for the organization.


Laura Harris, 40
Vice President Lott’s Furniture

In an industry where most people are 50+ in age, Laura began her career with Lott’s after graduating from Georgia Tech with high honors. She joined the 74-year old family business and opened a new store on Amelia Island, Florida in the midst of the 2008 downturn. The store has set record numbers each year and now has sales over $5M per year. She has opened, designed, and laid out an additional new store on Sadler Square, which opened in July 2018 and is considered by many as one of the most attractive stores in all of Florida. Here, she is responsible for buying and all displays in the 29,000 sq. ft. showroom. Laura is very involved in her community of Fernandina Beach, Florida, where she is on the Board of Directors of the Nassau County Chamber of Commerce. She has promoted donations to Joy to the Children by promoting Stress Less chairs through which she raised thousands of dollars to help support children at Christmas time with toys, clothing, bedding, books, and more.


Kyle Heikes, 27
Client Strategist FurnitureDealer.Net

In just two years at FurnitureDealer. Net, Kyle has become a trusted digital advisor to their clients, several of which are Top 100 retailers. He manages 30 retailer websites and has built strategic relationships with them to understand their business goals, create action plans, improve digital strategy, and identify ways to keep brands relevant using FurnitureDealer.Net’s platform. He worked closely with a Top 100 retailer to increase their e-commerce business by a whopping 55%! He created a “5 Best Practices for E-commerce” guide, a resource now used by FurnitureDealer.Net’s client base to help them grow their own e-commerce business.

Kyle earned his certifi cation in Google Ads and helped launch his company’s fi rst Google Ad Services program. In 2019, he single-handedly led that program, spending personal time confi guring how to run successful digital campaigns for clients. He has managed to drive paid traffi c that is just as good quality as organic traffi c- a rarity. Whenever asked what motivates him, Kyle always responds with “helping people.” He is active in Next Generation Now and volunteers on the registration team for the American Home Furnishings Hall of Fame dinner.


Rebecca Howsam, 29
Gallery Leader Restoration Hardware

After only four years at Restoration Hardware, Rebecca rose from sales associate to gallery leader. She is the point person that keeps the Birmingham RH Gallery running and sets the vision and culture for the team. Being in the community for just over one year, she leverages the community connections she made to educate both trade partners and clients on the ways RH can serve them. As a leader, she seeks out connections internally by forming coaching partnerships with each of her team members. She is always adapting her teaching style to fi t the team and fi nds ways to boost their skills. When the gallery was closed due to COVID-19, she found ways to keep her team motivated, productive, and excited. Under her leadership, the Birmingham location is ranked among the top within the company, which is quite an accomplishment considering Birmingham is a much smaller market than those in New York, LA, and the like. While working in New Orleans at the RH Metairie Gallery, Rebecca served on the team that designed and created costumes for Mardi Gras. She also volunteered with the New Orleans Fruit Tree Project.


Caitlin Jascewsky, 28
Marketing Supervisor Storis

Caitlin is responsible for the daily operations and strategic vision of the Storis marketing department. This includes supervising a team, their workloads, and their personal growth. Caitlin exemplifi es a talented, focused, and inspiring professional impacting the future of the industry. She consistently exceeds her personal and professional goals and takes initiative to set new benchmarks. Her eff ort regularly delves into the bett erment of retailers. She uses her creativity to think beyond retail technology to get to the heart of what will help consumers delight in their experiences with the home furnishings industry. There are many facets to Caitt in’s job including but not limited to overseeing website content and SEO performance. She also analyzes the strategy and eff ectiveness of marketing eff orts. Caitlin grew her career at Storis from marketing communications coordinator, then to communications & digital specialist, to her current supervisory position. Caitlyn was recognized as one of the Women on the Rise in 2018, and is a presenter at the annual ICFA Conference. She volunteers with Habitat for Humanity, and Pass It Along, Christmas in the City, where she helps secure age appropriate gifts for children.


Jenni Kimpel, 37
Sr. Director, Final Mile Business Development J.B. Hunt Transport

Expanding final mile solutions to provide more value to customers in the furniture industry is Jenni’s main focus at J.B. Hunt. She brings a burst of energy as she leads her team to building new solutions for delivery in a changing world. With her background in industrial engineering and her can-do approach to innovation, she’s able to combine real numbers with a hard-to-fi nd human touch in a challenging area. She is establishing a foundation and a set of tools that will benefi t all sides of the marketplace for years to come. Jenni was recognized in the Engineering and Technology group as a Engineering MVP in 2017. This, along with her performance, led to Jenni being asked to join the Engineering and Technology Executive Team. Jenni is a recipient of The College of Engineering Early Career Alumni Award, which recognizes the exceptional professional and personal achievements of University of Arkansas College of Engineering graduates.

Jenni was named Board Member of the year (2019) for the Northwest Arkansas Cystic Fibrosis Foundation Chapter. She is the auction chair of the chapter’s largest fundraising event. Jenni was also a mentor for Industrial Engineering students at the University of Arkansas.


Isaac Knorr, 36
President Knorr Marketing

Isaac has worked his way up the ladder at Knorr Marketing and has helped transition the company from a traditional full-service agency to an omni-channel agency that focuses on results and accountability. He began his career with the agency in 2006 as production department manager. In 2011, he transitioned to the account team and helped develop the agency’s KnorrWeb Internet platform. He was named COO in 2018 and president in 2019. Isaac is a key reason Knorr is a leader in providing marketing and advertising for home furnishing retailers. He has facilitated various emerging technologies that benefi t their clients. One of these technologies helps target IP addresses to serve online ads that match-back retail sales to home addresses. Another imperative technology uses OTT (over-the-top) to deliver commercials and target specifi c demographics/psychographics that match a retailer’s customer profi le on Internet and Online Streaming TV programming. Isaac has presented numerous seminars in the HFA Retail Resource Center during markets. He directs the Knorr Community Project, which works with local groups to enhance the lives of the people of the Grand Traverse Region.


Bryce Larson, 27
Director of Marketing Maven

At 27, Bryce has already risen through the ranks and garnered respect from colleagues. He works continuously to understand the market through in-store analysis of packaging and trending items, which infl uences the direction Maven takes with new products. He is described as proactive, motivated, intelligent, and a hard worker. Bryce specializes in licensing and recently helped secure a deal with Dr. Oz. He helps pitch to potential retail partners and then works to manage relationships and projects. He is preparing for an ambitious fall launch of a line that is projected to hit millions of dollars. One of his most ambitious plans has been creating brand teams. With multiple brands being developed with diff erent voices, audiences, and styles, Bryce’s brand managers make sure the representation of the brand across all platforms is consistent, helping to minimize ineffi ciencies, streamline communication, and diff erentiate brands. Larsen sits on the Friends Board of the local Children’s Justice Center, an organization that helps child victims of abuse. He has traveled around the world with his family to both fund and volunteer for projects that bring clean water to underserved areas.


Logan Matthews, 31
Store Manager Turner Furniture
Furniture First Buying Group member
Impact Consulting Performance Group member

Logan Matt hews is a maverick! His leadership skills and drive to succeed are admirable. He built an outstanding team at his store location and surpassed store sales volume goals in his fi rst year as the store manager. Logan is a transformational leader who strives to provide a phenomenal guest experience and takes pride watching his team members grow. He brings his own high standards to the team so that store guests really do benefi t. In 2019, Logan’s team ended the year with over $1,000,000 in matt ress sales volume, breaking all records since the store’s opening. He reached new heights with metrics of top volume, most comp over last year, top in fabric protection, top in bedding, and top in recliners. In 2019, Logan’s store location was voted by the community as the best place to purchase furniture and matt resses out of all furniture stores in town. Every year his store donates to United Way. That same year, he and the Turner family helped to refurbish an entire home that was lost due to a house fi re.

Marcus Moore, 33
VP of Marketing & Advertising Morris Furniture Company
FMG Buying Group member

With a can-do att itude, Marcus is responsible for driving shoppers into all 20 of the Morris Furniture showrooms. Using data, he is maximizing ad dollars to reach today’s shoppers in new ways with great results. He sets high standards for his team and motivates associates throughout the company. His extensive ad agency experience has helped Morris move beyond traditional media platforms in more eff ective ways. He has brought a fresh perspective to the leadership team and is able to initiate new programs in a decisive manner. He has expanded online sales success by creating a Live Chat team and improved the speed of the online sales entry process, has improved email marketing ROI and implemented a text marketing campaign. Morris Furniture Company partners with local organizations to provide beds to kids that do not have a bed of their own. Marcus was instrumental in helping improve the visibility of these programs so these organizations can raise more money in the future. The Pink Ribbon Girls help fi ght cancer and Marcus encouraged our company to support this organization by providing furniture for their conference room.


Brian Morgan, 36
Co-Owner Austin’s Couch Potatoes Furniture
First member

Brian is one of three Couch Potato owners that started in the furniture business from scratch, living in the warehouse, and growing their business to a substantial level in nine years. Despite advice to not manufacture their own upholstery, Brian is part of the team that not only made it happen, but also made it successful. They have built a thriving retail chain of stores that has grown to three locations with a fourth, larger location being built in partnership with the Furniture Mall of Kansas— the Furniture Mall of Texas is under construction. As the Covid-19 crisis grew, Marcus helped the company pivot and shift their in-house upholstery production to the production of masks and PPE. The community-minded focus of Brian’s leadership style is apparent in the store’s social media posts throughout the Covid-19 closure as the store shifted production to making masks and PPE for front line workers. Brian is also a board member of Hopegivers International.


Stuart Stump Mullens, 31
Partner Stump & Company

As a partner at Stump & Company, Stuart is responsible for all phases of merger & acquisition work, beginning with fundamental fi nancial analysis, and working with furniture clients to execute the sale of their business. She manages preparation of all off ering memorandum materials, managing the sale process, and leading the legal negotiations and fi nal sequencing of the closing. Now in her 5th year at Stump, she has quickly gained the trust and respect of numerous CEOs in the furniture industry through her professionalism, decorum, and integrity. She has received superior remarks from clients and team members in the execution of over 16 transactions, all in the furniture industry. She has quickly become a visible face and leader in the industry. Stuart is an active member of WithIt, a speaker at High Point Furniture Market Industry Overview events, and a candidate of MBA level graduate courses to support her concept of continuous improvement. She is a member of the University of Virginia Jeff erson Scholar Selection Committ ee (she was a Jeff erson Scholar and continues to support her alma mater), and an active member of her church.


Alexandra O’Hare, 32
VP of Merchandising and Strategic Initiatives
Hooker Furniture Corporation

Alexandra possesses a rare mix of intelligence, common sense, and consumer and industry insights that makes her extremely eff ective across multiple disciplines within Hooker Furniture. She manages merchandising for key categories within Hooker casegoods brands, manages their showrooms, and also has oversight responsibility for the development and execution of new strategic initiatives across the legacy Hooker brands. Alexandra was able to not only bring exceptional products to market, she also helped reorganize and reposition the showrooms, established go forward plans across numerous new strategic initiatives, and developed a new SKU analysis process that has allowed us to increase our SKU management and planning processes multi-fold. Her ability to take ideas from ideation to execution is remarkable and undoubtedly will continuously expand her value to both Hooker Furniture and the wider industry. Alexandra is an active member of the Junior League of High Point, has been active with the Communities in Schools mentorship program, and has recently become a member of the charitable Garden Club of Martinsville and Henry County.


Eric Poupard, 36
Regional Manager Hudson’s Furniture
Impact Consulting Performance Group member

Eric has been instrumental in Hudson’s Furniture’s continued eff orts to help its customers throughout the COVID-19 pandemic. When the company needed a way to communicate quickly and effi ciently with staff , Eric led the way through his use of the Podium system while also overseeing sales for his region. He kept everyone at Hudson’s Furniture in the loop and ready to roll by training and helping the team to organize while simultaneously updating the Podium system. Always the fi rst to volunteer for a project, he leads his teams with a smile, confi dence, and a positive att itude without fail. This trait is contagious and inspires those he works with and meets. Eric donates a very generous amount of his time off to assist with new Hudson’s Furniture staff growth and keeps the current staff prepared not only for the present, but also for the future. Eric continues to seek out opportunities for personal development and consistently cultivates ways to improve work fl ow through effi ciency, budget awareness, and determination. Hudson’s Furniture staff and its customers are up to date and prepared because of Eric’s hard work during the COVID19 crisis.


Rodd Rafieha, 30
Senior Vise President Abbyson

An expert in the home furnishings wholesale market and sales channel distribution, Rodd is a professional that fully supports his team. He is an Internet entrepreneur with exceptional knowledge and experience in sales and marketing. He put his creative mind and strategic business skills together to develop Abbyson’s award winning drop ship program. He built the drop ship program and retail business each to multi-million dollar heights. Rodd exemplifi es success in business management, operations, merchandising, brand development, and managing high volume at a national level. Rodd is an accomplished furniture designer who is not afraid to innovate using new technology. He created Abbyson’s patented iTable mini, which allows users to control their motion furniture’s functionality from anywhere that is visible. Rodd works tirelessly to make sure his partners feel valued and heard. When hit with tariff s, he came up with a game plan for every single one of his accounts to help them maintain and grow their businesses. Rodd donates to A Sense of Home, a local children’s charity. He utilizes sustainability practices when designing furniture and helped implement an environmentally friendly workspace for the Abbyson corporate offi ces.


Erfan Reed, 37
Senior Software Developer Malouf

As a senior software developer, Erfan manages the software engineering team. He specializes in development, web projects, apps, electronics, and fi rmware. Under his leadership his team built three diff erent custom printed circuit boards for diff erent applications. His creativity and proactive att itude have helped move Malouf into the realm of technology. He leads his team in pioneering out-of-the-box initiatives including a custom warehouse management system. When members from Amazon toured Malouf’s facility, they said it was the most sophisticated, and user-friendly system they had ever seen. The team is currently updating the technology of a new distribution center, which will eliminate 14 hours of manual labor per week and provide more accurate data. They are also building out capabilities for an integrated home automation program that allows users to control their adjustable base across multiple smart home devices. Reed entered the United States as a refugee from Iran in 2008 and became a United States citizen in 2013. He is using his life experience to help others through the Cache Refugee and Immigrant Connection.

Emily Robinson, 35
Design Director Glen Raven – Sunbrella

Emily has dedicated over 10 years to developing and designing one of the worlds most trusted indoor and outdoor performance fabrics. She worked her way up from a designer out of NC State Design School to becoming a design director at Sunbrella in 10 years. She leads a team of 12 designers and oversees and manages the creation of over eight new fabric collections every year. But Emily does not just design. She is also a key asset to the sales team and the overall success of the entire organization. She travels on many sales calls to customers’ locations and has developed strong and fruitful relationships with industry leaders. Emily supports animal shelters through adoption. She is active in her local church as well as in the healthcare community in her town of Burlington, NC.


Mario Vizcarra Sanchez, 38
General Manager Ashley Furniture HomeStore

Furniture was not just a career choice for Mario—it became a lifeline after a horrifi c car accident landed him in a wheelchair from 17–21. He did not know what the future would hold, but when the furniture industry came into his life it gave him a reason to live. Mario is responsible for the daily operations of an Ashley HomeStore in El Centro, CA. Driving results through training and accountability, he developed a sales team that knows how to hit their mark. When Mario took over the store, sales increased nearly $1M after the fi rst year and almost $2M after the second year. Matt ress sales increased 20%. During COVID-19 when the store closed and the staff was laid off Mario single handedly kept sales going using marketing techniques, social media, and cold calling. Mario is the son of Mexican immigrants and fi eld workers who worked hard to bring their family to the U.S. He always looks for ways to help those in need. Mario speaks publicly at churches and rehab’s homes to build up the local community with positivity & pride.


Desiree L. Sauerbrey, 40
Account Manager Hickory Springs Manufacturing

Desiree is a proven sales leader for HSM, ranking among the top two in sales revenue within Hickory Springs’ foam fabricators sales division for furniture-component related sales. With 12 years of experience serving the High Point, North Carolina region, she is a forward thinking business professional with a goal-oriented mindset that increasingly delivers solid results. Managing four of the company’s top-tier major accounts for furniture and foam products, she consistently meets or surpasses her sales goals with existing customers and continuously fi nds strategic new accounts for the company. Her technical understanding of HSM products, competitive knowledge and experience working with the company’s operations team to problem solve and gain effi ciencies deserves recognition. In addition to her residential furniture and bedding components expertise, she boasts extensive knowledge of the hospitality industry. She also manages a diverse portfolio of products for the company’s diversifi ed products division. Sauerbrey is very active in her local church, teaching Children’s Church for the past 12 years. Committed to helping those in need, she has also been involved in her church’s Shepard’s Inn and Baby Meal Ministries.


Patrick Shelton, 32
Vice President of Sales Valdese Weavers

Patrick oversees sales activity for all of the Valdese Weavers brands and is at the forefront of developing new and eff ective sales strategies that will provide an elevated service level and product to its customers. He has trained in nearly every department during his ten-year tenure, which has provided him with the ability to understand diff erent perspectives and appreciate how important every department is to the success of the company. This experience proved critical during the developmental phases of proprietary performance brands by allowing him to bridge the gap between departments and challenge the norms of what each believed was possible, resulting in the fi rst all-inone performance fabric on the market today. Patrick has been a leader in the expansion of performance fabrics into the residential market and was instrumental in developing the InsideOut and Sustain Performance Fabrics brands. Patrick supports fundraisers for cancer research, The American Heart Association and Miracle Hill Ministries, South Carolina’s largest provider of homeless services. He frequently participates in industry panel discussions and is asked to lead educational seminars about textiles.


Paul Toms III, 36
VP Lifestyle Brands, Perigold and Wayfair Canada Wayfair, Inc.

At 34 years old, Paul has accomplished great things for Wayfair. He worked his way up through the organization and has become a driving force in their growth. His leadership across the lifestyle brands added signifi cantly to the overall volume of the Wayfair company with much of it due to identifying and hiring great people, as well as his exceptional work ethic. Under his leadership, the Joss & Main brand hit its true stride functioning as a fl ash sale platform for a large segment of consumers. Paul was the thought leader behind the birth and development of the Perigold brand. He has been able to help many furniture executives bett er understand the value of executing against the pure-play space. Paul is very involved in the diversity initiatives at Wayfair and serves as the executive liaison for WayBlack, a resource group for employees who identify as African-American, African, or Caribbean. He serves as Chairman of The Hyannis Sound, helping to bring a cappella music performance and education to the Cape Cod area.


Marlene Vidal, 35
Corporate Sales & Marketing Manager Coaster Company of America

With a wide range of responsibilities Marlene has a proven track record of developing, implementing and executing projects, budgets, business plans, contracts and promotional campaigns. She is also the liaison between the marketing, sales, and product development teams to ensure brand consistency and success. Marlene has been in the furniture industry for over 10 years. She began her career at Direct Buy as an Interior Design Associate. Since then, she climbed the corporate ladder to become the sales and marketing manager for a leading North American furniture distributor. She is an ambitious individual with passion and wisdom. She single handedly implemented a new customer relationship management system for Coaster’s sales team, which has been very successful. She has implemented and trained the sales team on in-store kiosk programs and restructured the marketing department to be more eff ective and effi - cient to ensure their success. For the past 4 years, Marlene has been an active volunteer, att endee and donor at numerous fundraisers within the furniture industry supporting the City of Hope.


Victoria Vizard, 34
Manager, Web Advisor Group MicroD

Victoria is responsible for developing customer relationships promoting retention and loyalty. She enables success by ensuring clients are satisfi ed with the services they receive. She has risen from an advisor role to a leadership role where she helps more than 350 furniture retailers. She played a key role on the team that delivered an industry-leading B2B e-commerce platform for a major furniture manufacturer. Victoria skillfully wrote a customer success measurement system that pulled client satisfaction data points from diff erent systems to ensure all clients receive the service level and support they expect. She also provides strategic direction to MicroD developers for improvements to the OmniVue e-commerce platform. These improvements have directly led to more sales leads and increased sales for the company’s clients. Victoria is active in coaching and mentoring her team and serving as a leadership resource for colleagues. Victoria has volunteered at a rescue and rehab facility for horses coming from abusive situations, as well as a facility that serves children with disabilities, teaching them how to ride and care for their own horse.


Josh Walter, 38
BrandJump CEO

Co-founder and CEO Josh Walter launched Brandjump in 2011. Since then the company has become a leading e-commerce sales and marketing fi rm in the home furnishings industry. The unique model delivers merchandising, content, and marketing expertise to optimize their clients’ online presence and drive revenue through Internet retail channels. Josh leads the team and is directly responsible for new business opportunities. He has assembled a team of talented young professionals and has created a business model that no one to this point has emulated. Josh is a young entrepreneur with a visionary mindset. His ability to create a company that has not yet been matched within the industry proves that what he has done is not easily replicated. Prior to co-founding BrandJump, Josh served in a business development role at Light, a decorative lighting sales agency. Josh received his JD/MBA from Pepperdine, and is a member of the California Bar. Supporting Habitat for Humanity is important to Josh. He is working with the local chapter in Los Angeles to raise the required amount in funds and donations to achieve his dream of building a home.


Cameron Wanek, 28
Senior Vice President, Business Analytics & Supply Chain Planning Ashley Furniture

At the age of 13, Cameron started his journey at Ashley working with the ground crews after school. Since then, he has performed most jobs within the company. He is currently responsible for Ashley’s production and inventory control teams, thus closing the loop on holding all of the major supply chain planning positions into a single team. This encompasses over 21,000,000 sq. ft. of manufacturing and distribution worldwide. Cameron leads a team that executes integrated analytics, inventory planning, and supply chain functions. They are implementing Artificial Intelligence for “real-time” data science that will allow for increased efficiency. Cameron is also focused on developing a cloud-based accountability process to track assignment workflows. The program results have led to increased efficiencies with savings of 25%-30%. His commitment to knowledge-based systems has dramatically impacted Ashley’s HomeStore Retail logistical business. This new system and process has already impacted efficiencies and product availability by over 10%. Cameron is the driving force behind the City of Hope Wanek Family Program to Cure Type 1 Diabetes.


Jessica Weber, 36
Director of Merchandising and Marketing Montgomery’s Furniture First member

Jessica is a game-changer. She has the ability to look past the status quo to find new and more efficient processes while being a great leader and team player. Within three years of joining Montgomery’s, Jessica became Director of Merchandising and Marketing. She is responsible for the overall leadership, growth, and strategic planning of the Merchandising department, where she works closely with merchandisers to lead planning, stay on top of trends, gross margin optimization, and inventory management. Jessica is extraordinarily selfless. She is always doing things for others even though she has an extremely busy schedule. She holds a leadership role in her organization’s Culture Club, which ensures the company’s culture is upheld through social interactions and employee recognition. She attended the University of South Dakota and got her B.A. in Business Administration, and B.S. in Contemporary Media & Journalism, Marketing, Advertising, and Public Relations. Jessica’s dedication and knowledge are apparent from the moment you meet her. Her knowledge of the business reaches far beyond merchandising and marketing.

Leadership: One Size Does Not Fit All

There is no one-size-fi ts-all template for how to be a great leader. Sometimes people will respond to your entrepreneurial mindset or creativity, and other times it’s the support and guidance you give that motivates and inspires those around you. But one thing all leaders have in common is that they work tirelessly to push their teams forward.

Forbes contributor Brent Gleeson, who writes about leadership and organizational excellence, offered the following insight in a May 2019 article highlighting what great leaders focus on: 1. The result not the task. As opposed to good leaders, great leaders have a unique talent for defi ning a clear vision, gett ing feedback on that vision, gaining buy-in, proving boundaries and inspiring creative solutions. They assign a result, not necessarily the tasks associated with achieving that result. That is the team’s job.

2. Leading and following. Great leaders understand the true dichotomy of leadership: leading and following. They know when to shut up and get out of the way – knowing when they are sometimes the obstacle standing in the way of team success.

3. Serving from the boom. Similar to knowing when to lead and when to follow, great leaders are authentic servants of their people. They put the needs of the team before their own. Not simply the “needs” associated with mission success, but also the individual needs of each team member. Their org chart looks like an upside-down pyramid.

4. Allowing creativity and innovation. Once the desired “result” has been defi ned and agreed upon by the team, great leaders know how to align rituals, behaviors and actions with achieving that outcome. Innovation and creativity are imperative not just for keeping team members engaged but also for driving the best possible results. This mechanism is the cultural bedrock of the highest-performing teams in special operations and in business.

5. Developing themselves then others. Great leaders are in a constant state of self-improvement. Not just in their ability to lead, but also in mental and physical wellness. They are usually avid readers and fi tness enthusiasts. Most importantly, they crave transparent feedback from those around them. Good leaders are open to feedback while great leaders apply that feedback and take action. They know they can’t authentically develop others unless they develop themselves. Constantly.

6. Transformational leadership. A transformational leader goes beyond managing day-to-day operations and crafts strategies for taking her company, department or work team to the next level of performance and success. Transformational leadership styles focus on teambuilding, motivation and collaboration with employees at all levels.

Cover Story: Will We Ever Put Humpty Dumpty Back Together Again?

After weeks of denials and minimization at the federal level, reality set in and “shelter in place” became a fact. The positives disappeared. The graphic shown below of traffi c into the stores fell precipitously. The statistics are a national sample of a range of free-standing independent retailers. Whatever the market or size of store, furniture retailing in brick and mortar stopped.

The retail activity across all furniture retail outlets, no ma er traditional furniture stores or the broader based home furnishings stores, stopped. In comparison to all other retail, the downturn in furniture retailing was signifi cant. Stocking up on hand sanitizer and toilet paper was in the forefront of consumer purchases. Along with this, consumer prices in April dropped by .8% —the most since the Great Recession—after falling .4% in March. The drop was weighed down by a plunge in demand for gasoline and services, such as air travel. However, furniture and bedding doubled that, falling 1.9% in April and 1.4% in March, which is 12 MAY/JUNE 2020 HFBUSINESS.COM the largest decline since December of 2008 during the fi nancial crisis. One thing you can rely on is as sales soften, furniture retailers will discount.

Where does the industry go from here? Unfortunately, the typical independent retailer cannot withstand a loss of more than 10% of sales before going into the red. The chart below presents the statistics. While the statistics are based upon 2018 fi gures, there will be li le change when 2019 results are completed. Obviously, larger retailers fare be er and can withstand a 23% loss of revenue.

WERE THERE PROBLEMS BEFORE?
Before this all started, the furniture / bedding industry model was developing some serious cracks. The impact of e-tailing, which emerged in the early 2000s, became a serious concern in the second decade of the new century with a level of 20% in 2019. With declining gross margin per square foot of selling space in the discount chains brought about by overexpansion of stores dictating the closing of stores, the furniture product category’s gross margin became attractive. With Target stores adding furniture collections and Big Lots focusing on the furniture category, the traditional furniture stores felt pressure in the lower promotion price points.

The traditional furniture stores, the home of middle price points and representing 50-60% of industry sales, have migrated into the lower part of the upper price points, forcing the upper end stores to compete at lower margins or close. This upper end collapse has created a market for interiors decorators that provide not only better design, but a shopping assist for the time starved consumers. Serving this market is also the lifestyle stores, such as Restoration Hardward, Arhaus, and Pottery Barn. With smaller stores focused on a target consumer, this segment has expanded. For the last fi ve years, regional chains have expanded signifi cantly, pushing out the small independents in the markets over $50m in furniture/bedding sales. While 2019 saw a decline in expansion, the major shock was the collapse of the Art Van franchise after being acquired. Widely accepted as a failure of execution by the venture capital fi rm, Thomas Lee, the result is still the same. This failure caused the re-emergence of the belief that a national furniture retailer is not possible – Levitz, Wickes – Heilig-Myers. What have Raymour & Flanigan, Haverty’s, and Rooms To Go discovered?

WHAT IS IN THE FORECAST?
At the writing of this article, the Commerce Department announced that the Home Furnishings category was down 66.25% in April compared to the same quarter last year. For traditional brick and mortar furniture retailers, the reaction was most likely, “I would be delighted with 33% of my 2019 April sales, in that my stores were shu ered.” However, the resilience of furniture retailers came through as they learned how to create VIRTUAL SALES via e-commerce, phone, social media, or by appointment. This 33% compared to last year is the starting point for rebuilding sales volume. It should be pointed out again that this 33% fi gure is signifi cantly below the breakeven point for all furniture stores, which is 10.3% down, as discussed earlier.

Understanding what that future holds is the major questions of furniture retailers as they reopen stores. As of the writing of this article, many retailers that reopened in the fi rst few weeks of May had a pleasant surprise, achieving sales that matched or exceeded 2019.

While the traffic was down 50%, the consumer came ready to purchase with close rate doubled and average tickets up 50%. The question is, will this result hold or is it the pent up demand from the six weeks prior?

To better understand the future, we need to understand the factors that impact the furniture industry’s performance. The chart below presents those factors that statistically influenced FurnitureCore’s Industry Model over the past 30 years. (FurnitureCore is the parent company of Home Furnishings Business.) These factors are presented below with the red highlight on the impacted factors in the past months.

How do these statistics translate into what industry sales will be for the balance of the year? There is no statistical confi - dence in projecting from these emerging numbers. However, when CONSUMER CONFIDENCE fell to the 86%+/- level, the industry declined 27.9%. Likewise, when UNEMPLOYMENT entered the 14%+/- range, the industry fell 35%. We all remember the 2007-2008 period. HOUSING STARTS, which fell 22% last month, interrupted a 20% growth rate. Housing starts are a factor impacting industry sales in Q4/2020.

In a survey conducted of larger retailers, the majority (35%) believed sales would decline 10-20%, but 20% believed the decline would be 20% or more. From the perspective of these same retailers, the deciding factor will be the consumer attitude. Getting them back into the stores (63%) and creating a clean environment (29%) were their major concerns.

The success of furniture retailers returning to a “new normal” will be determined by the management team being open to new ideas and accepting that it will not go back to what it was before. There were casualties in the Great Recession and there will be as well in the Pandemic of 2020. But furniture retailing will continue.

Cover Story: Will the Retail Experience Become the Advertising?

Furniture retailers responded creating a web presence. Initially, many were placeholders as there was a “land stampede” for domain names. Now, those placeholders have transformed into signifi cant presentations of not only product, but also the variance in the retailer’s services that make them uniquely diff erent from their competitors. Today, depending upon the merchandise price point, 72% of consumers visit the Internet during the buying process for research.

This presents the obvious question, “of the consumers actively considering or shopping for furniture within my market footprint, how many are visiting my website and how many are visiting my store?” Current research updated quarterly via FurnitureCore, the research arm of Home Furnishings Business, measures the stage of shopping for consumers as shown in Graphic A. Obviously these percentages vary by age group with 39% of the 35-54 age group having begun the buying process compared to the other age groups at 30%.

Understanding how many unique visitors come to your website is provided by Google analytics and is well accepted as the most accurate source of this data. Combining this with your store traffi c counts will provide a good perspective of how your advertising is impacting your performance. Graphic B combines all of these statistics into one graphic.

For many retailers, this visual is often a shock when they see the diff erence between those visiting their site and those visiting their stores. However, considering that consumers may visit more than seven websites on average, but only shop 2-3 stores indicates the challenge of bringing customers into the physical store (Graphic C).

Obviously, this statistic varied by age / income reflecting the demographics and depending upon the advertising media used to convey product differences.

Comparing the unique visitors to the retailer’s website to the number of consumers actively engaged in shopping for furniture is just as important. A large defi cit indicates that consumers are not considering the retailer. This factor measures the brand awareness of the retailer. Considering recent fi nancial fi lings by Casper that indicated expenditures of $400M in advertising to achieve 31% added brand awareness emphasizes the challenge. Consumer research that asks which retailers were considered, shopped, and purchased from measures the retailer’s market position. Graphic D presents the findings in a typical market.

Advertising is the process of changing these statistics. Having more consumers considering your store and having more consumers visiting your store after viewing your website is the objective. The advertising strategy of the retailer should be influenced by the media that most influences the consumer target. The leading influencer, according to recent research, is the Internet, followed almost equally by television and magazines combined.

Graphic E presents the findings. Obviously these statistics would vary by age with the younger consumer < 45 years of age, indicating television as 13.25% compared to older consumers 45+ at 17.90%. Again, the retailer must select the advertising media for the consumer they are targeting. For that reason, lifestyle retailers, such as Pottery Barn and RH (Restoration Hardware), use direct mail and social media as these mediums are the preference of the 45 age segment.

Interestingly, from a financial perspective, traditional retailers (independents / regional chains) expend significantly more on television (broadcast). The breakdown as a percentage of sales is shown in graphic F. Beyond the how of advertising is the what? What is the specific message that will most motivate the consumer to select you as the retailer of choice? The messages must start with the why. Graphic G shows the consumer is purchasing replacement furniture (43.95%), and is based upon recent research that explores the most relevant reason for the consumer to make a purchase.

For industry veterans, this is an astonishing statistic as it has more than doubled in the past 20 years. In fact, there was a feeling then that we “built our furniture too well,” and, “should we consider an obsolescence factor?” Unfortunately, a frayed sofa doesn’t create the same sense of urgency as a broken refrigerator. It is, therefore, a postponed purchase.

As can be seen from Graphic G, “desire for new furniture” is just over 27% of purchase motivators. However, for our prime furniture buyer age 25-54, a recent move and remodeling are over 50% of the purchase motivators. The importance of direct mail to influence the new movers is well justified with over 25% of purchases from this demographic. As would be expected, when the consumer’s reason to purchase is driven by furniture replacement, quality (29%) would be the most important feature that attracted the consumer to the product they purchased (Graphic H).

While quality is consistent across all age groups as being of importance, warranty is much more important to the 35-54 age segment, being the segment that have experienced the decline in quality first hand. The opportunity to provide warranty is a significant opportunity to add profitability. A key profitability item in appliances and electronics has not been fully executed in furniture retailing.

While the purchase motivator for new furniture is style representing only 25%, it does present an opportunity for larger tickets and higher margin. Where does the consumer get their style inspiration? Again, the Internet (37.5%) is the primary response, but there are other important infl uences as shown in Graphic I.

As you would expect, for our emerging furniture purchasers (25-34) age group, the Internet is more important. However, retail stores represent less than half. Are we creating the visual experience in our stores?

What ultimately motivated the consumer to purchase? Unfortunately, the manufacturer and retailer reputation contributed less than a third of the motivation (Graphic J). Again, the repeat of quality as the prime motivation was the consensus. From an advertising perspective, the most diffi - cult element to communicate is quality. In advertising, the substitute for quality is brand.

Finally, we must consider the financial aspect of advertising. Unless you have fi nancial backers, such as Casper, you cannot aff ord to spend 33% of revenue on advertising. A percentage in the 5.5% to 6.0% range would be appropriate. The table below (Graphic K) presents the statistics by retailer’s revenue.

Beyond the advertising expense must be the eff ectiveness of advertising. In other words, does your advertising bring the consumer through the door? The most common measure is the cost per up. The industry average can be seen in Graphic L .

As can be seen, the smaller retailer < $5M is at a signifi cant disadvantage. Advertising in furniture retailing today has become more challenging. While the Internet can be a more eff ective medium to communicate considering our time-starved consumer, it is diffi cult to communicate the quality. What is emerging is the direct to consumer brands. These manufacturing direct brands are Omni-channels with unique brands with unique points of diff erences, begun on the Internet and moving to physical stores will be their strategy. The need to expand customer bases will drive the need for brick and mortar.

However, their stores will be customer experience focused. By that, they will be personalized, frictionless, and enjoyable, staff ed by passionate sales associates. The stores will be smaller, less high-price environments focused on brand building assets, such as digital screens. The new retail will be data driven, putt ing the consumer experience first. Maybe the retail experience will become the advertising. We are beginning to serve the experience generation.

EMP
Performance Groups
HFB Designer Weekly
HFBSChell I love HFB
HFB Got News
HFB Designer Weekly
LinkedIn